Pipeline Parity
BabelFHIR-TS Report
A babelfish on TypeScript and FHIR
Validator parity across FHIR R4 & R5 Implementation Guides. Each profile is tested with empty() and random() resource generation, then validated against the HL7 Java Validator, the Firely SDK Validator, and BabelFHIR-TS internal validate() + Zod schemas.
Metric Definitions
View Docs
- Empty Validation Parity (external)
- Do internal and reference validator (Firely / HL7) report the same errors for
empty()resources? - Random Validation Parity (external)
- Do internal and reference validator report the same errors for
random()resources? - Random Generation Validation + Parity (external)
- Do
random()resources pass reference validator validation with zero errors? - Empty Validation Parity (internal)
- Do
validate()and Zod schema agree onempty()resources? - Random Validation Parity (internal)
- Do
validate()and Zod schema agree onrandom()resources? - Random Generation Validation + Parity (internal)
- Do
random()resources pass internalvalidate()with zero errors?
Latest Release main v1.6.12
Trend Chart (18 runs)
HL7FirelyInternal
Average overall % across empty parity, random parity & random validation per pipeline run (18 runs)
HL7 Java Validator v6.10.4
Sep 5, 2026, 11:39 UTC
Empty Validation Parity
100%
657/657
Random Validation Parity
100%
703/704
Random Generation Validation + Parity
76%
536/704
Per-package breakdown (31 packages)
| Package | Empty Validation Parity | Random Validation Parity | Random Generation Validation + Parity |
|---|---|---|---|
| 🇨🇭 CH Core 6.0.0 | 28/28 (100%) | 29/29 (100%) | 29/29 (100%) |
| 🌍 IPS 2.0.1 | 27/27 (100%) | 27/27 (100%) | 27/27 (100%) |
| 📦 Isik Medikation 4.0.3 | 8/8 (100%) | 8/8 (100%) | 8/8 (100%) |
| 🔐 SMART 2.2.0 | 6/6 (100%) | 6/6 (100%) | 6/6 (100%) |
| 🇺🇸 US Core 9.0.0 ⚠️ | 41/41 (100%) | 54/54 (100%) | 54/54 (100%) |
| 📦 Cpg 2.0.0 ⚠️ | 96/96 (100%) | 98/98 (100%) | 93/98 (95%) |
| 📦 Genomics Reporting 3.0.0 | 17/17 (100%) | 17/17 (100%) | 16/17 (94%) |
| 🇩🇪 ISiK Basis 4.0.3 ⚠️ | 25/25 (100%) | 25/25 (100%) | 23/25 (92%) |
| 📦 Sdoh 2.3.0 | 20/20 (100%) | 20/20 (100%) | 18/20 (90%) |
| 📦 Qicore 7.0.2 | 65/65 (100%) | 65/65 (100%) | 58/65 (89%) |
| 📦 Physical Activity 1.0.0 | 16/16 (100%) | 16/16 (100%) | 14/16 (88%) |
| 📦 Mcode 4.0.0 | 37/37 (100%) | 38/38 (100%) | 31/38 (82%) |
| 📦 Au Core 2.0.0 ⚠️ | 13/13 (100%) | 20/20 (100%) | 16/20 (80%) |
| 📦 Davinci Pdex 2.1.0 | 13/13 (100%) | 13/13 (100%) | 10/13 (77%) |
| 📦 Ndh 1.0.0 ⚠️ | 31/31 (100%) | 30/30 (100%) | 23/30 (77%) |
| 📦 Emedicinal Product 1.0.0 | 15/15 (100%) | 15/15 (100%) | 11/15 (73%) |
| 📦 Davinci Pas 2.2.1 | 29/29 (100%) | 29/29 (100%) | 20/29 (69%) |
| 📦 Davinci Drug Formulary 2.1.0 | 8/8 (100%) | 8/8 (100%) | 5/8 (63%) |
| 📦 Vitals 1.0.0 | 1/1 (100%) | 15/15 (100%) | 9/15 (60%) |
| 📦 Sdc 4.0.0 | 34/34 (100%) | 34/34 (100%) | 20/34 (59%) |
| 📦 Cqfmeasures 5.0.0 ⚠️ | 12/12 (100%) | 12/12 (100%) | 6/12 (50%) |
| 📦 Davinci Deqm 5.0.0 | 11/11 (100%) | 11/11 (100%) | 5/11 (45%) |
| 📦 De Basisprofil 1.6.0 | 9/9 (100%) | 19/19 (100%) | 8/19 (42%) |
| 📦 Carin Bb 2.2.0 | 16/16 (100%) | 16/16 (100%) | 6/16 (38%) |
| 📦 Pixm 3.1.0 | 11/11 (100%) | 11/11 (100%) | 4/11 (36%) |
| 📦 Mhd 4.2.4 | 31/31 (100%) | 31/31 (100%) | 11/31 (35%) |
| 📦 Davinci Cdex 2.1.0 | 7/7 (100%) | 7/7 (100%) | 2/7 (29%) |
| 📦 Davinci Dtr 2.2.0 | 14/14 (100%) | 14/14 (100%) | 2/14 (14%) |
| 📦 Davinci Alerts 1.1.0 | 8/8 (100%) | 8/8 (100%) | 1/8 (13%) |
| 📦 Ae Research 1.0.1 | 1/1 (100%) | 1/1 (100%) | 0/1 (0%) |
| 📦 Kbv Erp 1.4.4 ⚠️ | 7/7 (100%) | 6/7 (86%) | 0/7 (0%) |
Firely SDK Validator v3.3.1 on Hl7.Fhir 6.4.0
Sep 5, 2026, 11:34 UTC
Empty Validation Parity
100%
666/666
Random Validation Parity
93%
616/665
Random Generation Validation + Parity
74%
492/665
Per-package breakdown (31 packages)
| Package | Empty Validation Parity | Random Validation Parity | Random Generation Validation + Parity |
|---|---|---|---|
| 📦 Carin Bb 2.2.0 ⚠️ | 6/6 (100%) | 6/6 (100%) | 6/6 (100%) |
| 📦 Davinci Pdex 2.1.0 ⚠️ | 12/12 (100%) | 11/11 (100%) | 11/11 (100%) |
| 🇩🇪 ISiK Basis 4.0.3 ⚠️ | 26/26 (100%) | 26/26 (100%) | 26/26 (100%) |
| 📦 Isik Medikation 4.0.3 | 8/8 (100%) | 8/8 (100%) | 8/8 (100%) |
| 🔐 SMART 2.2.0 | 6/6 (100%) | 6/6 (100%) | 6/6 (100%) |
| 🇺🇸 US Core 9.0.0 | 55/55 (100%) | 55/55 (100%) | 55/55 (100%) |
| 📦 Genomics Reporting 3.0.0 | 17/17 (100%) | 17/17 (100%) | 16/17 (94%) |
| 📦 Physical Activity 1.0.0 ⚠️ | 12/12 (100%) | 12/12 (100%) | 11/12 (92%) |
| 📦 Mcode 4.0.0 ⚠️ | 35/35 (100%) | 35/35 (100%) | 30/35 (86%) |
| 📦 Au Core 2.0.0 ⚠️ | 20/20 (100%) | 20/20 (100%) | 16/20 (80%) |
| 📦 Ndh 1.0.0 ⚠️ | 28/28 (100%) | 28/28 (100%) | 21/28 (75%) |
| 📦 Pixm 3.1.0 | 11/11 (100%) | 11/11 (100%) | 4/11 (36%) |
| 📦 Davinci Cdex 2.1.0 | 7/7 (100%) | 7/7 (100%) | 1/7 (14%) |
| 📦 Ae Research 1.0.1 | 1/1 (100%) | 1/1 (100%) | 0/1 (0%) |
| 📦 Cpg 2.0.0 ⚠️ | 96/96 (100%) | 93/96 (97%) | 76/96 (79%) |
| 🌍 IPS 2.0.1 ⚠️ | 25/25 (100%) | 24/25 (96%) | 24/25 (96%) |
| 📦 Davinci Pas 2.2.1 ⚠️ | 22/22 (100%) | 21/22 (95%) | 15/22 (68%) |
| 📦 Sdoh 2.3.0 ⚠️ | 16/16 (100%) | 15/16 (94%) | 12/16 (75%) |
| 🇨🇭 CH Core 6.0.0 | 29/29 (100%) | 27/29 (93%) | 22/29 (76%) |
| 📦 Sdc 4.0.0 | 34/34 (100%) | 31/34 (91%) | 20/34 (59%) |
| 📦 Davinci Deqm 5.0.0 | 11/11 (100%) | 10/11 (91%) | 5/11 (45%) |
| 📦 Qicore 7.0.2 | 65/65 (100%) | 56/65 (86%) | 50/65 (77%) |
| 📦 Davinci Drug Formulary 2.1.0 ⚠️ | 7/7 (100%) | 6/7 (86%) | 5/7 (71%) |
| 📦 Davinci Dtr 2.2.0 | 14/14 (100%) | 12/14 (86%) | 2/14 (14%) |
| 📦 Cqfmeasures 5.0.0 | 13/13 (100%) | 11/13 (85%) | 6/13 (46%) |
| 📦 Mhd 4.2.4 ⚠️ | 30/30 (100%) | 25/30 (83%) | 10/30 (33%) |
| 📦 Vitals 1.0.0 | 15/15 (100%) | 12/15 (80%) | 13/15 (87%) |
| 📦 De Basisprofil 1.6.0 | 19/19 (100%) | 14/19 (74%) | 8/19 (42%) |
| 📦 Emedicinal Product 1.0.0 | 15/15 (100%) | 11/15 (73%) | 12/15 (80%) |
| 📦 Davinci Alerts 1.1.0 ⚠️ | 3/3 (100%) | 2/3 (67%) | 1/3 (33%) |
| 📦 Kbv Erp 1.4.4 | 8/8 (100%) | 3/8 (38%) | 0/8 (0%) |
Internal (validate + zod)
Sep 5, 2026, 11:30 UTC
No data available yet.
⏱ Validation Timing — 3196 resources: validate() 24.96s, Zod 4.39s, HL7 4140.03s, Firely 1619.06s
| Package | Resources | Val Total | Val Avg | Zod Total | Zod Avg | HL7 Total | HL7 Avg | Firely Total | Firely Avg |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ae-research | 10 | 0.09s | 9.4ms | 0.02s | 1.7ms | 40.19s | 20092.5ms | 27.76s | 13878ms |
| au-core | 120 | 1.02s | 8.5ms | 0.17s | 1.5ms | 80.12s | 1602.3ms | 40.61s | 812.3ms |
| carin-bb | 44 | 0.99s | 22.6ms | 0.12s | 2.7ms | 124.97s | 3905.3ms | 33.7s | 1053.1ms |
| ch-core | 176 | 1.38s | 7.8ms | 0.2s | 1.1ms | 97.54s | 1681.7ms | 40.33s | 695.4ms |
| cpg | 264 | 0.99s | 3.8ms | 0.42s | 1.6ms | 225.87s | 1140.7ms | 64.53s | 325.9ms |
| cqfmeasures | 88 | 0.78s | 8.8ms | 0.16s | 1.8ms | 65.53s | 2520.5ms | 30.28s | 1164.7ms |
| davinci-alerts | 20 | 0.23s | 11.5ms | 0.05s | 2.4ms | 130.04s | 8127.7ms | 86.53s | 5408.3ms |
| davinci-cdex | 30 | 0.25s | 8.4ms | 0.1s | 3.2ms | 172.23s | 12302.3ms | 114.04s | 8145.6ms |
| davinci-deqm | 68 | 0.7s | 10.3ms | 0.09s | 1.4ms | 114.63s | 5210.5ms | 57.99s | 2636.1ms |
| davinci-drug-formulary | 42 | 0.4s | 9.5ms | 0.06s | 1.5ms | 126.59s | 7912.2ms | 51.09s | 3193.2ms |
| davinci-dtr | 192 | 1.23s | 6.4ms | 0.1s | 0.5ms | 272.9s | 9746.4ms | 65.85s | 2351.9ms |
| davinci-pas | 194 | 1.84s | 9.5ms | 0.23s | 1.2ms | 404.21s | 6969.2ms | 52.95s | 912.9ms |
| davinci-pdex | 118 | 0.47s | 4ms | 0.12s | 1ms | 427.02s | 16423.8ms | 39.64s | 1524.6ms |
| de-basisprofil | 170 | 0.82s | 4.8ms | 0.16s | 0.9ms | 39.38s | 1036.3ms | 40.52s | 1066.3ms |
| emedicinal-product | 30 | 0.17s | 5.8ms | 0.06s | 1.9ms | 45.2s | 1506.6ms | 38.33s | 1277.7ms |
| genomics-reporting | 96 | 0.38s | 4ms | 0.12s | 1.3ms | 73.89s | 2173.3ms | 34.11s | 1003.3ms |
| ips | 76 | 0.37s | 4.8ms | 0.13s | 1.7ms | 58.33s | 1080.3ms | 44.87s | 830.9ms |
| isik-basis | 126 | 2.44s | 19.4ms | 0.17s | 1.3ms | 60.26s | 1076ms | 33.82s | 603.9ms |
| isik-medikation | 32 | 1.01s | 31.6ms | 0.04s | 1.2ms | 61.74s | 3859.1ms | 23.46s | 1466.4ms |
| kbv-erp | 64 | 1.07s | 16.7ms | 0.08s | 1.2ms | 71.34s | 4458.6ms | 43.91s | 2744.1ms |
| mcode | 142 | 0.76s | 5.4ms | 0.21s | 1.5ms | 129.11s | 1698.8ms | 58.76s | 773.1ms |
| mhd | 78 | 0.92s | 11.8ms | 0.16s | 2ms | 169.24s | 2729.6ms | 57.29s | 924ms |
| ndh | 176 | 0.89s | 5.1ms | 0.19s | 1.1ms | 162.72s | 2624.5ms | 38.34s | 618.4ms |
| physical-activity | 38 | 0.54s | 14.1ms | 0.11s | 3ms | 75.49s | 2359.1ms | 57.75s | 1804.6ms |
| pixm | 30 | 0.35s | 11.6ms | 0.1s | 3.3ms | 69.31s | 3150.2ms | 36.69s | 1667.8ms |
| qicore | 172 | 0.8s | 4.6ms | 0.26s | 1.5ms | 275.01s | 2115.4ms | 98.42s | 757.1ms |
| sdc | 320 | 1.63s | 5.1ms | 0.26s | 0.8ms | 120.5s | 1772.1ms | 88.23s | 1297.5ms |
| sdoh | 50 | 0.53s | 10.5ms | 0.1s | 1.9ms | 142.57s | 3564.3ms | 45.56s | 1139ms |
| smart | 18 | 0.44s | 24.2ms | 0.04s | 2.4ms | 56.37s | 4697.4ms | 28.86s | 2405.3ms |
| us-core | 164 | 1.25s | 7.6ms | 0.29s | 1.8ms | 192.64s | 1751.3ms | 113.42s | 1031.1ms |
| vitals | 48 | 0.22s | 4.6ms | 0.07s | 1.5ms | 55.09s | 1836.3ms | 31.42s | 1047.3ms |
⏱ Generation Timing — 31 packages: 1085s total
| Package | Extract | Init | Resolve | Generate | Compile | Repack | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ae-research | 0.05s | 3.9s | 4.5s | 0.82s | 3.1s | 0.09s | 13.2s |
| au-core | 0.13s | 4.9s | 11.3s | 1.2s | 11s | 0.49s | 30.6s |
| carin-bb | 0.1s | 4.7s | 12.1s | 1.3s | 9s | 0.33s | 29.5s |
| ch-core | 0.17s | 4.5s | 5.9s | 1.2s | 11.9s | 0.54s | 25.7s |
| cpg | 0.3s | 4.4s | 2.9s | 2.1s | 21.4s | 0.85s | 34.3s |
| cqfmeasures | 0.22s | 4.3s | 7.8s | 1.1s | 9.1s | 0.48s | 23.8s |
| davinci-alerts | 0.05s | 5.6s | 20s | 0.91s | 5.9s | 0.22s | 33.1s |
| davinci-cdex | 0.09s | 5.2s | 38.5s | 0.83s | 6.1s | 0.25s | 51.5s |
| davinci-deqm | 0.13s | 4.8s | 18.7s | 2.3s | 7s | 0.29s | 34.2s |
| davinci-drug-formulary | 0.08s | 4.4s | 13.4s | 1.1s | 5.4s | 0.3s | 27.1s |
| davinci-dtr | 0.07s | 3.8s | 57.5s | 1.5s | 7.9s | 0.31s | 71.4s |
| davinci-pas | 0.2s | 4.3s | 53.7s | 1.6s | 15.1s | 0.6s | 76.3s |
| davinci-pdex | 0.14s | 6s | 57.9s | 1.4s | 10.3s | 0.44s | 77.4s |
| de-basisprofil | 0.11s | 4.3s | 0.57s | 0.88s | 9.6s | 0.34s | 17.8s |
| emedicinal-product | 0.06s | 5.4s | 2.9s | 3.8s | 4.3s | 0.12s | 20.1s |
| genomics-reporting | 0.21s | 4.2s | 2.6s | 0.52s | 9.2s | 0.41s | 18.3s |
| ips | 0.11s | 5.1s | 6.2s | 1.8s | 8.4s | 0.32s | 24.6s |
| isik-basis | 0.12s | 5.8s | 4.5s | 0.44s | 9.4s | 0.35s | 21.5s |
| isik-medikation | 0.05s | 4.2s | 3.9s | 62.8s | 5s | 0.24s | 76.5s |
| kbv-erp | 0.04s | 5.4s | 8s | 0.72s | 6.4s | 0.22s | 21.1s |
| mcode | 0.3s | 4.3s | 17s | 1.4s | 13.4s | 0.6s | 38.7s |
| mhd | 0.17s | 4.4s | 5.9s | 0.87s | 9.9s | 0.41s | 22.4s |
| ndh | 0.33s | 5.6s | 21.8s | 2.7s | 12.6s | 0.76s | 44.7s |
| physical-activity | 0.16s | 4.9s | 18.1s | 1.1s | 8.5s | 0.35s | 34.2s |
| pixm | 0.1s | 5.1s | 4.3s | 1s | 8.4s | 0.28s | 19.6s |
| qicore | 0.13s | 3.9s | 9.6s | 7.8s | 12.3s | 0.47s | 38.1s |
| sdc | 0.25s | 5.2s | 13.4s | 3.1s | 15.8s | 0.67s | 39.5s |
| sdoh | 0.1s | 3.8s | 19.3s | 1.8s | 6.9s | 0.25s | 32.9s |
| smart | 0.03s | 4s | 6.6s | 1.2s | 4.1s | 0.17s | 16.6s |
| us-core | 0.4s | 6.4s | 23.6s | 2.8s | 18.3s | 0.84s | 57.4s |
| vitals | 0.05s | 4.9s | 1.5s | 0.55s | 5.1s | 0.21s | 12.9s |
⚠️ Excluded Profiles — 62 exclusions both: 3 firely: 49 hl7: 10
Profiles excluded from parity statistics due to external issues (validator bugs, profile defects, or terminology limitations). BabelFHIR-TS generates valid resources for all of these.
Exclusion Patterns
| Pattern | Count | Affected Validator(s) |
|---|---|---|
| Discriminator evaluation failure | 22 | 22 firely |
| Element ordering (parser bug) | 21 | 21 firely |
| Bundled context required | 8 | 8 firely |
| Terminology server limitation | 4 | 4 hl7 |
| Missing snapshot | 4 | 4 hl7 |
| Cross-profile validation | 2 | 2 hl7 |
| SNOMED edition mismatch | 2 | 2 hl7 |
| Failed to parse validator output | 2 | 1 hl7 1 firely |
Excluded Profiles
| # | IG | Profile | Validator | Category | Scope | Error |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 📦 au-core | AUCoreMedicationClass | both | Firely: Element ordering (parser bug) HL7: Terminology server limitation |
empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely: Firely parser ordering bug: coding vs text HL7: tx.fhir.org: Australian ValueSet filter not understood |
| 2 | 📦 au-core | AUCoreMedicationRequestClass | both | Firely: Element ordering (parser bug) HL7: Terminology server limitation |
empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely: Firely parser ordering bug: coding vs text HL7: tx.fhir.org: Australian ValueSet filter not understood |
| 3 | 📦 cpg | CHFBodyWeightClass | both | Firely: Discriminator evaluation failure HL7: Cross-profile validation |
empty-parity | Firely: Firely cannot load the chf-bodyweight schema and validates against base Observation, so it reports only status and code HL7: HL7 bp |
| 4 | 📦 au-core | AUCoreBloodPressureClass | firely | Discriminator evaluation failure | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely cannot use the coding at Observation.component:SystolicBP.code as a discriminator when it is sliced to more than one choice |
| 5 | 📦 au-core | AUCoreConditionClass | hl7 | Terminology server limitation | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | tx.fhir.org: Australian ValueSet filter not understood |
| 6 | 📦 au-core | AUCoreImmunizationClass | firely | Element ordering (parser bug) | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely parser ordering bug: coding vs text |
| 7 | 📦 au-core | AUCorePathologyResultClass | firely | Discriminator evaluation failure | empty-parity | Unmatchable value discriminator at Observation.category:specificDiscipline.coding.code; Firely abandons the schema and validates against base Observation |
| 8 | 📦 au-core | AUCoreProcedureClass | hl7 | Terminology server limitation | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | tx.fhir.org: Australian ValueSet filter not understood |
| 9 | 📦 au-core | AUCoreSmokingStatusClass | hl7 | SNOMED edition mismatch | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | SNOMED AU code not in International Edition |
| 10 | 📦 carin-bb | C4BBExplanationOfBenefitInpatientInstitutionalBasisClass | firely | Element ordering (parser bug) | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely parser ordering bug: coding vs text |
| 11 | 📦 carin-bb | C4BBExplanationOfBenefitInpatientInstitutionalClass | firely | Element ordering (parser bug) | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely parser ordering bug: coding vs text |
| 12 | 📦 carin-bb | C4BBExplanationOfBenefitOralBasisClass | firely | Element ordering (parser bug) | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely parser ordering bug: coding vs text |
| 13 | 📦 carin-bb | C4BBExplanationOfBenefitOralClass | firely | Element ordering (parser bug) | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely parser ordering bug: coding vs text |
| 14 | 📦 carin-bb | C4BBExplanationOfBenefitOutpatientInstitutionalBasisClass | firely | Element ordering (parser bug) | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely parser ordering bug: coding vs text |
| 15 | 📦 carin-bb | C4BBExplanationOfBenefitOutpatientInstitutionalClass | firely | Element ordering (parser bug) | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely parser ordering bug: coding vs text |
| 16 | 📦 carin-bb | C4BBExplanationOfBenefitPharmacyBasisClass | firely | Element ordering (parser bug) | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely parser ordering bug: coding vs text |
| 17 | 📦 carin-bb | C4BBExplanationOfBenefitPharmacyClass | firely | Element ordering (parser bug) | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely parser ordering bug: coding vs text |
| 18 | 📦 carin-bb | C4BBExplanationOfBenefitProfessionalNonClinicianBasisClass | firely | Element ordering (parser bug) | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely parser ordering bug: coding vs text |
| 19 | 📦 carin-bb | C4BBExplanationOfBenefitProfessionalNonClinicianClass | firely | Element ordering (parser bug) | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely parser ordering bug: coding vs text |
| 20 | 📦 cpg | CHFO2SatClass | firely | Discriminator evaluation failure | empty-parity | Firely cannot load the chf-oxygensaturation schema and validates against base Observation, so it reports only status and code |
| 21 | 📦 cpg | CHFPotassiumClass | firely | Discriminator evaluation failure | empty-parity | Firely cannot load the chf-potassium schema and validates against base Observation, so it reports only status and code |
| 22 | 📦 cqfmeasures | CQFMPublishableMeasureClass | hl7 | Failed to parse validator output | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | HL7 validator crashes — unparseable output |
| 23 | 📦 davinci-alerts | AdmitNotificationMessageHeaderClass | firely | Bundled context required | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Profile requires aggregation: bundled; standalone parity not meaningful |
| 24 | 📦 davinci-alerts | ADTNotificationCoverageProfileClass | firely | Bundled context required | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Profile requires aggregation: bundled; standalone parity not meaningful |
| 25 | 📦 davinci-alerts | ADTNotificationEncounterProfileClass | firely | Bundled context required | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Profile requires aggregation: bundled; standalone parity not meaningful |
| 26 | 📦 davinci-alerts | DischargeNotificationMessageHeaderClass | firely | Bundled context required | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Profile requires aggregation: bundled; standalone parity not meaningful |
| 27 | 📦 davinci-alerts | NotificationsMessageHeaderClass | firely | Bundled context required | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Profile requires aggregation: bundled; standalone parity not meaningful |
| 28 | 📦 davinci-drug-formulary | FormularyDrugClass | firely | Element ordering (parser bug) | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely parser ordering bug: coding vs text |
| 29 | 📦 DaVinci PAS | PASClaimBaseClass | firely | Discriminator evaluation failure | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Claim.careTeam:OverallClaimMember points a value discriminator at a boolean with no fixed[x] or pattern[x] |
| 30 | 📦 DaVinci PAS | PASClaimClass | firely | Discriminator evaluation failure | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Claim.careTeam:OverallClaimMember points a value discriminator at a boolean with no fixed[x] or pattern[x] |
| 31 | 📦 DaVinci PAS | PASClaimInquiryClass | firely | Discriminator evaluation failure | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Claim.careTeam:OverallClaimMember points a value discriminator at a boolean with no fixed[x] or pattern[x] |
| 32 | 📦 DaVinci PAS | PASClaimUpdateClass | firely | Discriminator evaluation failure | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Claim.careTeam:OverallClaimMember points a value discriminator at a boolean with no fixed[x] or pattern[x] |
| 33 | 📦 DaVinci PAS | PASDeviceRequestClass | firely | Element ordering (parser bug) | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely parser ordering bug: coding vs text |
| 34 | 📦 DaVinci PAS | PASEncounterClass | firely | Element ordering (parser bug) | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely parser ordering bug: coding vs text |
| 35 | 📦 DaVinci PAS | PASTaskClass | firely | Element ordering (parser bug) | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely parser ordering bug: coding vs text |
| 36 | 📦 davinci-pdex | PdexMedicationDispenseClass | firely | Element ordering (parser bug) | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely parser ordering bug: coding vs text |
| 37 | 📦 davinci-pdex | PDexMultiMemberMatchRequestParametersClass | firely | Discriminator evaluation failure | random-parity, random-validation | Profile bug: hrex-consent policy:hrex slice uses 'value' discriminator without fixed/pattern |
| 38 | 🌍 IPS | CompositionUvIpsClass | firely | Discriminator evaluation failure | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely rejects the resolve() discriminator at Composition.section:sectionMedications.entry:medicationStatementOrRequest, which FHIR R4 permits |
| 39 | 🌍 IPS | DiagnosticReportUvIpsClass | firely | Discriminator evaluation failure | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely rejects the resolve() discriminator at DiagnosticReport.result:observation-results, which FHIR R4 permits |
| 40 | 🇩🇪 ISiK Basis | ISiKAngehoerigerClass | firely | Discriminator evaluation failure | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | RelatedPerson.name:Name declares a pattern discriminator and sets no pattern[x] to match on |
| 41 | 🇩🇪 ISiK Basis | ISiKDiagnoseClass | hl7 | Missing snapshot | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Profile ISiKDiagnose |
| 42 | 🇩🇪 ISiK Basis | ISiKProzedurClass | firely | Element ordering (parser bug) | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely parser ordering bug: coding vs text |
| 43 | 🇩🇪 ISiK Basis | ISiKVersicherungsverhaeltnisGesetzlichClass | hl7 | Missing snapshot | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Profile ISiKVersicherungsverhaeltnisGesetzlich |
| 44 | 🇩🇪 ISiK Basis | ISiKVersicherungsverhaeltnisSelbstzahlerClass | hl7 | Missing snapshot | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Profile ISiKVersicherungsverhaeltnisSelbstzahler |
| 45 | 📦 kbv-erp | KBVPRERPBundleClass | hl7 | Missing snapshot | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Profile KBV_PR_ERP_Bundle |
| 46 | 📦 mcode | GenomicVariantClass | firely | Element ordering (parser bug) | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely parser ordering bug: version vs display |
| 47 | 📦 mcode | LymphomaStageClass | firely | Element ordering (parser bug) | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely parser ordering bug: coding vs text |
| 48 | 📦 mcode | TNMStageGroupClass | firely | Discriminator evaluation failure | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely rejects the $this.resolve() discriminator at Observation.hasMember:TNMCategory, which FHIR R4 permits |
| 49 | 📦 mhd | FindDocumentReferencesResponseClass | firely | Discriminator evaluation failure | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Bundle.entry:DocumentReference has a discriminator that always succeeds, so it cannot separate the slice from any other entry |
| 50 | 📦 ndh | NdhNdApiPractitionerClass | firely | Bundled context required | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely snapshot generator internal error on Extension.extension.value[x] (ElementMatcher.constructChoiceTypeMatch) |
| 51 | 📦 ndh | NdhNdApiPractitionerRoleClass | hl7 | SNOMED edition mismatch | random-parity, random-validation | SNOMED code '453091000124108' not in International Edition |
| 52 | 📦 ndh | NdhPnLdApiPractitionerClass | firely | Bundled context required | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely snapshot generator internal error on Extension.extension.value[x] (ElementMatcher.constructChoiceTypeMatch) |
| 53 | 📦 ndh | NdhPractitionerClass | firely | Bundled context required | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely snapshot generator internal error on Extension.extension.value[x] (ElementMatcher.constructChoiceTypeMatch) |
| 54 | 📦 physical-activity | PACarePlanClass | firely | Failed to parse validator output | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely SDK internal XML parsing error on generated JSON resource |
| 55 | 📦 physical-activity | PAConditionLowPAClass | firely | Discriminator evaluation failure | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely rejects the resolve() discriminator at Condition.evidence.detail:SupportedDetail, which FHIR R4 permits |
| 56 | 📦 physical-activity | PADiagnosticReportClass | firely | Discriminator evaluation failure | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely rejects the resolve() discriminator at DiagnosticReport.result:SupportedResult, which FHIR R4 permits |
| 57 | 📦 physical-activity | PAGoalClass | firely | Discriminator evaluation failure | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely rejects the $this.resolve() discriminator at Goal.addresses:PAIssues, which FHIR R4 permits |
| 58 | 📦 sdoh | SDOHCCConditionClass | firely | Discriminator evaluation failure | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely rejects the resolve() discriminator at Condition.evidence.detail:SupportedDetail, which FHIR R4 permits |
| 59 | 📦 sdoh | SDOHCCObservationEthnicityOMBClass | firely | Discriminator evaluation failure | empty-parity | Unmatchable value discriminator at Observation.component:EthnicityDescription.value[x]; Firely abandons the schema and validates against base Observation |
| 60 | 📦 sdoh | SDOHCCObservationRaceOMBClass | firely | Discriminator evaluation failure | empty-parity | Unmatchable value discriminator at Observation.component:RaceDescription.value[x]; Firely abandons the schema and validates against base Observation |
| 61 | 📦 sdoh | SDOHCCTaskForPatientClass | firely | Discriminator evaluation failure | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | Firely rejects the resolve() discriminator at Task.partOf:SupportedPartOf, which FHIR R4 permits |
| 62 | 🇺🇸 US Core | USCoreVitalSignsProfileClass | hl7 | Cross-profile validation | empty-parity, random-parity, random-validation | HL7 bp |
🔧 Excluded Fields — 31 field-level exclusions
Specific fields excluded from parity comparison because validators report them incorrectly. The profile still passes, but these fields are tolerated.
| # | IG | Profile | Validator | Field(s) | Category | Scope | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | au-core | AUCorePatientClass | firely | country, pattern, unclassified | Discriminator evaluation failure | random-parity | Firely validates against an identifier slice whose discriminator the instance does not satisfy, and omits the fixed country and system we report |
| 2 | au-core | AUCorePractitionerClass | firely | country, type, pattern, unclassified | Discriminator evaluation failure | random-parity | Firely validates against an identifier slice whose discriminator the instance does not satisfy, and omits the fixed country and system we report |
| 3 | au-core | AUCorePractitionerRoleClass | firely | type, pattern, unclassified | Discriminator evaluation failure | random-parity | Firely validates against an identifier slice whose discriminator the instance does not satisfy, and omits the fixed country and system we report |
| 4 | au-core | AUCoreRelatedPersonClass | firely | country, type, system, pattern, unclassified | Discriminator evaluation failure | random-parity | Firely validates against an identifier slice whose discriminator the instance does not satisfy, and omits the fixed country and system we report |
| 5 | cpg | CPGCommunicationRequestClass | firely | modifierextension | Validation model difference | empty-parity | Firely reports min=0 mustSupport slice modifierExtension:intent as a required slice; the SD sets min=0 max=1 |
| 6 | cqfmeasures | CQFMRatioMeasureClass | firely | population, unclassified | Validation model difference | random-parity | Firely aborts at the first structure it cannot parse, so it never evaluates the further findings we report on the same resource |
| 7 | cqfmeasures | CQFMContinuousVariableMeasureClass | firely | population, unclassified | Validation model difference | random-parity | Firely aborts at the first structure it cannot parse, so it never evaluates the further findings we report on the same resource |
| 8 | davinci-cdex | CDexTaskAttachmentRequestClass | firely | code, constraint, contained, resourcetype, reference | Validation model difference | random-parity | Firely aborts at the first structure it cannot parse, so it never evaluates the further findings we report on the same resource |
| 9 | kbv-erp | KBVPRERPBundleClass | firely | pattern | Validation model difference | empty-parity | Both validators report the meta.profile fixed-value mismatch; Firely anchors it to no element so it classifies as `pattern` while ours classifies as `meta` |
| 10 | au-core | AUCorePatientClass | hl7 | country | Validation model difference | random-parity | HL7 resolves au-address and au-base but does not report the fixed country, fixed identifier system or required type they pin |
| 11 | au-core | AUCorePractitionerClass | hl7 | country, type, unclassified | Validation model difference | random-parity | HL7 resolves au-address and au-base but does not report the fixed country, fixed identifier system or required type they pin |
| 12 | au-core | AUCorePractitionerRoleClass | hl7 | type | Validation model difference | random-parity | HL7 resolves au-address and au-base but does not report the fixed country, fixed identifier system or required type they pin |
| 13 | au-core | AUCoreRelatedPersonClass | hl7 | country, type, system, unclassified | Validation model difference | random-parity | HL7 resolves au-address and au-base but does not report the fixed country, fixed identifier system or required type they pin |
| 14 | au-core | AUCoreMedicationStatementClass | hl7 | unclassified | Terminology server limitation | random-parity | tx.fhir.org: Australian ValueSet filter not understood |
| 15 | davinci-pdex | PDexMultiMemberMatchRequestParametersClass | hl7 | constraint | Validation model difference | random-parity | HL7 rejects example.org URLs in Consent.policy.uri via a built-in rule, not a FHIRPath constraint in the SD; reported intermittently |
| 16 | de-basisprofil | VitalSignDEArterielleSauerstoffsaettigungPulsoximetrieClass | hl7 | coding | Discriminator evaluation failure | random-parity | HL7 $this discriminator limitation: undercounts coding:loinc slice matches (reports min=2 found=1 despite 3 LOINC codings present) due to faulty $this pattern evaluation inherited from base VitalSignDE profile |
| 17 | de-basisprofil | VitalSignDEArterielleSauerstoffsaettigungPulsoximetrieClass | hl7 | pattern | Validation model difference | random-parity | HL7 reports one fixed-value violation twice, anchored to both profiles that pin the unit; we report it once |
| 18 | de-basisprofil | VitalSignDEAtemfrequenzClass | hl7 | pattern | Validation model difference | random-parity | HL7 reports one fixed-value violation twice, anchored to both profiles that pin the unit; we report it once |
| 19 | de-basisprofil | VitalSignDEHerzfrequenzClass | hl7 | pattern | Validation model difference | random-parity | HL7 reports one fixed-value violation twice, anchored to both profiles that pin the unit; we report it once |
| 20 | de-basisprofil | VitalSignDEKoerperkerntemperaturClass | hl7 | pattern | Validation model difference | random-parity | HL7 reports one fixed-value violation twice, anchored to both profiles that pin the unit; we report it once |
| 21 | de-basisprofil | VitalSignDEArterielleSauerstoffsaettigungClass | hl7 | pattern | Validation model difference | random-parity | HL7 reports one fixed-value violation twice, anchored to both profiles that pin the unit; we report it once |
| 22 | isik-basis | ISiKAngehoerigerClass | hl7 | constraint | Discriminator evaluation failure | random-parity | RelatedPerson.name:Name declares a pattern discriminator and sets no pattern[x], so slice membership cannot be decided |
| 23 | isik-basis | ISiKProzedurClass | hl7 | unclassified | Terminology server limitation | random-parity | tx: OPS code system version in the ValueSet include ("*") does not match the version on the code, which tracks the current OPS year |
| 24 | mhd | ProvideDocumentBundleResponseClass | hl7 | unclassified | Bundled context required | random-parity | bdl-8 FHIRPath empty propagation: fullUrl.contains(/_history/).not() yields empty when fullUrl absent; fhirpath.js all() returns false, HL7 returns true |
| 25 | mhd | ComprehensiveProvideDocumentBundleClass | hl7 | constraint, entry, pattern | Validation model difference | random-parity | Bundle entry slice validation model difference: our validator matches entries by resourceType and delegates to sub-profile validators (catching code+extension errors), while HL7 uses conformsTo-based matching and reports entry-level slice rejection + pattern mismatch. Both detect the same underlying issues (wrong code, missing extensions) but organize errors across different field categories. |
| 26 | mhd | MinimalProvideDocumentBundleClass | hl7 | constraint, entry, pattern | Validation model difference | random-parity | Bundle entry slice validation model difference: our validator matches entries by resourceType and delegates to sub-profile validators (catching code+extension errors), while HL7 uses conformsTo-based matching and reports entry-level slice rejection + pattern mismatch. Both detect the same underlying issues (wrong code, missing extensions) but organize errors across different field categories. |
| 27 | mhd | UnContainedComprehensiveProvideDocumentBundleClass | hl7 | constraint, entry, pattern | Validation model difference | random-parity | Bundle entry slice validation model difference: our validator matches entries by resourceType and delegates to sub-profile validators (catching code+extension errors), while HL7 uses conformsTo-based matching and reports entry-level slice rejection + pattern mismatch. Both detect the same underlying issues (wrong code, missing extensions) but organize errors across different field categories. |
| 28 | sdc | SDCQuestionnaireExtractTemplateClass | hl7 | extension | Empty parity field miss | empty-parity | HL7 misses inherited min=1 on Questionnaire.url (tightened by sdc-questionnaire) |
| 29 | vitals | BodyLengthClass | hl7 | constraint | Cross-profile validation | random-parity | HL7 measures body length (LOINC 8306-3, absent from the core vital-signs value set) against core bodyheight and demands its BodyHeightCode slice, LOINC 8302-2; reported intermittently |
| 30 | vitals | HeadOccipitalFrontalCircumferenceClass | hl7 | constraint | Cross-profile validation | random-parity | HL7 measures head circumference by tape measure (LOINC 8287-5, absent from the core vital-signs value set) against core headcircum and demands its HeadCircumCode slice, LOINC 9843-4; reported intermittently |
| 31 | vitals | BloodPressurePanelClass | hl7 | component | Cross-profile validation | random-parity | HL7 applies core bp (component 2..*, DiastolicBP 1..1) to LOINC 85354-9; blood-pressure-panel itself declares component 1..* with DiastolicBP 0..1 |